vinyl debate ultimately comes down to personal preference and the listening experience you seek. Edit; I forgot I have one. Bluebook The right price. Posted April 21, 2010. They also don’t degrade with each playback, unlike analog records. Since this mess I want to compare more where I have overlap. It is probably a more accurate rendition of the master tape but with my turntable and on. By all means, get the 4 DCC's. Both vinyl records and Super Audio CDs have. Moody Blues "Question of bal. Anyway, my sense is that good vinyl and good SACD are probably comparable but there are a lot of other variables such as quality of the music system etc. Roxanne Joncas Soundstage determines the stereo image width you perceive between the speakers. I do have two different versions of "Question of Balance". What do you think about SACD vs Vinyl in sound terms? I know it has been deiscussed but if you feel like answer me now after some years after its. . We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. " CD or SACD vs Vinyl. Even as a purist I am very happy with the results. Digital vs. 98. Forums. I see a trend, and I tend to do this myself, looking for older "original" cd releases of stuff if there are one or multiple re-masters available today. Very pleasing, I like it. 1kHz/16-bit digital audio is indistinguishable from high-resolution digital. The authors aren’t saying that high-res digital might sound a little different from Red Book CD but is no better. Hello everybody. In the end it really comes down to the transfer and the mastering. I have SACD that beats my vinyl and vice versa. I don't know which is more truthful. There are also the hybrid SACD discs from AP but I am not as familiar with those. The separation between the left and right channels on vinyl is 30dB, compared to digital files, which exceed 90 dB. Ironically, the royalty for an SACD was the same as for a CD: $. The authors aren’t saying that high-res digital might sound a little different from Red Book CD but is no better. Under perfect circumstances, SACD provides an incremental improvement over CD. BD Pure Audio is basically the same as DVD-A except it's encoded to 96/24. Dam and Dorian75 like this. swinger Member Thread Starter. The LP may sound more natural and "warm". Disagree. I always remember the SACD being pretty good, but I now think the vinyl destroys it. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. The SHM-SACD is based off a copy tape and the HDTracks download is compressed. Usually, more attention was paid to the mastering of 50s and 60s LPs and currently, SACDs. Tony van Veen is the CEO of DIY Media Group, the parent company of Disc Makers and BookBaby. . #13. However, I have tested the EQ of my cartridge and phono stage and in all the following examples, that EQ has been reversed out of the vinyl samples so that what we're comparing is the true EQ of what's in the LP groove. Two channel SACD just blew away the CD's, while hybrids were not out yet I had albums that I had both the CD and the SACD to compare. 7 gigabytes per disk (as much as a DVD), SACD can accommodate separate stereo and six-channel mixes of 100 minutes each. Consequently, the Super Audio CD (SACD) was developed by Philips and Sony. Sample Rate: 2. I noted underneath your review of the box set that the new SHM-SACD was a flat transfer from the analogue master. $750. Boy, what a difference. label will be coming to hybrid stereo SACD (playable on all CD players) as well as to audiophile-standard UltraDisc One-Step 180-gram, 45 RPM vinyl. Look how far CD sound has come in the last 20. SACD vs. The album was developed from a collection of unrelated. As a college student, he played in indie bands, created his own LPs, cassettes, and t-shirts, and sold them at shows. The remastering has added the humanity and warmth Mozart requires. Shawn, Dec 8, 2012. I am intrigued by it but don't know if it would really give me any better quality for some recordings than what I already have. Warner Music [Sony Music outside Europe] today announced the upcoming release of Pink Floyd’s ‘Animals’ on Deluxe Gatefold, CD, LP, Blu-ray and SACD. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. 1 setup. . In 1973, the Best Of The Doors compilation album was issued on quadraphonic LP, 8-track, and reel formats. CD was based on limited video tape storage capacity, and also on 1970s computing power. The DCC versions have more punch and bass, but the AP SACD's are more flat and crisp. The original purpose was a sonic comparison of MQA to SACD in the physical realm. The higher the bitrate, the better the sound quality. The difference between 24/192 and DSD is that the DSD sounds more analog like, but this is not a huge difference in overall sound quality. Please login or registerlogin or registerThe primary difference noted between the LP and SACD was the increased soundstage and depth of the SACD. After an extensive shoot-out lasting 53 hours, I'm. Dylan 'Desire' MFSL SACD and vinyl* Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Jack White, Aug 2, 2013. The internet has not only changed. I think my buying strategy just morphed into buying a few LPs which I really want and then stocking up on the less expensive SACDs, particularly if the. 45 RPM 200 Gram Clarity Vinyl. 98: Whitney Houston / Whitney. g. I received Hank Mobley, Mobley's Message and also Jackie. Sonos does not likely play DSD. I go between the US Sony SACD and the 35DP depending on mood. Newly remastered by Bernie Grundman, from the original analog master tapes! Includes both mono and stereo mixes — Pure DSD sound! *cd layer contains stereo mix only. The world's largest online retailer of high-end audio, audiophile music, and accessories. It was mastered by Bob Ludwig in December 2002. Boy, what a difference. ? I jumped into the SACD thing because I wanted agood digital source for my CDs so I said why not pay some more and get SACD. Merch Rep the community and hobby you love so much. #6. It is a high end format accessible to someone who doesn't want to mess with a protractor, cleaning records or flipping a disc every 20 minutes. . Bluebook The right price. It sounds like MoFi master their vinyl and SACD separately. Rolling Stone 500 Greatest Albums of All Time — rated 30/500! " Are You Experienced appeared in the U. Dec 10, 2005. Please login or register an accountlogin or register an accountMoody Blues "Question of bal. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. redbook vs. They pretty much mirror each other in my opinion. I like both; but am buying more hi-q vinyl than SACD, DVD-A, or HDCD simply because remastered 180g vinyl is easier to find in the genres I listen to: Rock, alt. We do plan on releasing a limited run of virgin vinyl 45rpm pressings—probably 500 pieces—sometime next month if we’re able. But they always compares SACD vs CD on the same player. 1447) Join Date Dec 2011 Location Tynemouth, England Posts 2,457 Mentioned 43 Post(s)SACD vs. Data read from an SHM CD is no different to the data red from an ordinary CD. The differences between them, resolution wise, are huge since XRCD is a pure red book format at 16/44. Mirror Image, Sep 16, 2022. Great sounding discs are much, much more frequent than on redbook, and it comes with none of the hassles of vinyl attached, plus you can rip the redbook layer and take it. I like Analogue Productions' work, so it should be interesting to hear how they sound. Tommyboy, May 30, 2020. DJM CD very excellent as is the MCA clone mastering of the DJM. That leaves Soft Parade which also was released by Audio Fidelity. All that being written, the dilemma, SACD vs. I have two completely different setups for vinyl, and digital, and my vinyl is always a little more bass and drums heavy, past that, no glaring differences. If you prefer extended frequency in the. Dylan 'Desire' MFSL SACD and vinyl* Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by Jack White, Aug 2, 2013. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. Szeppelin75, Nov 7, 2016. SACD Players SACD stands for Super Audio CD. 1k Posted October 24, 2003 The XRCD probably had a goosed up high end and somebody was fooled into preferring it. (Believe it or not, this was a major argument in some of the original SACD sales literature. Whilst many (recent) multichannel SACDs are more about ambience, others are about using the system to provide an immersive sound (e. I hate the snaps clicks and pops of vinyl. What you're saying about DACs, i. Would someone out there who has the vinyl and has compared it to either the MFSL CD or the newer SACD please. Still waiting form "Brothers in Arms" on SACD I have also ordered the MoFi vinyl releases of: "Love Over Gold", "Dire Straits" and "Brothers in Arms" I look forward to comparing SACD vs Vinyl *reelspin* My thought process is I should buy them while they are relatively new and prices have not reached $200+ each yet. The vinyl appears to be analogue mastered so if you value an all-analogue chain that would be an advantage. That depends on what you are looking for. The difference between DSD and the source vinyl was very, very slight and I am not sure I could tell the difference on any given day. This first example compares MoFi' s Music From Big Pink - LP vs. One is the MFSL version which I loved. Direct Stream Digital (DSD) is a trademark used by Sony and Philips for their system for digitally encoding audio signals for the Super Audio CD (SACD). Packaging: Nicest packaging and faithful reproduction of the original album. 4. I no longer have the capability of playing vinyl. Normally in making CD/LP comparisons from the same masters the poorer separation necessitated by the physical matrixing of the two channels into a single vinyl groove is hardly noticed, but this time it was extremely apparent. #20. Then I bought the new SACD version. The yellow arrow indicates the rise in noise above 30 kHz in the SACD due to the DSD64 encoding. Owned by CEO Chad Kassem, who founded the company in 1986, Acoustic Sounds is a global retailer of the largest selection of highest-quality music in a variety of formats. #5. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. I did a similar shoot out to yours above with the sax and vocal section at the end of Avalon with the SACD and UK first press vinyl. After that, what format is it available in? And which represents the best mastering? It's as simple as that. Tell me what you think, do you prefer SACD's or Vinyls because they sound the same to me, only you get the 5. Gallery. Pacific 2 SE -> Ayon Crossfire III or Circle Labs A100 -> Avantgarde Acoustic Trio LE 26 with 4x REL Carbon Special ,SACD Player: Audio Aero La Fontaine Analog : Transrotor Fat Bob S. In other forum in Madrid we have carried out the test with the Stereophile material and I'm anxious to know if yo have done the same overhere and what results you have obtained. I don’t care what they claim they did to the CD. however you need to be extra careful as there are many SACDs where the MultiCh content is not only distinct in being a different mix but a different mastering from the Stereo and that Stereo version can often just be a recycling of the current CD remaster the label had at the. The world's largest high-end audio community. There are very few times I like the CD better than the LP. Fourth - 45 rpm vinyl . SACD (1999) uses completely different 1-Bit method of encoding so it is hard to extrapolate, but best guess, SACD is about. While the standard CD format is tied to a 44. The MoFi also has surface noise,while the Abkco vinyl is near silent. SACD (white) vs Bluray (blue) The pressing quality of 2022 vinyl is not always perfect, but often a wash will solve the problem. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Slight increase in frequency range and they also have a lot more features on the Blu-ray disc that are fun to play with. The Beethoven symphony cycle on LSO Live (Haitink, 2006) is an SACD hybrid set. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. The wait is over for the Analogue Productions SACD. The string attack, decay, soundstage, and imaging are way ahead of the SACD. SACD Players SACD stands for Super Audio CD. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. SHM-SACD vs UK Vinyl. One of the benefits of SACD is the dead quiet background. 8224. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. 24 bit: Best of the bunch. Elton John Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (D1) (2004 Rocket SACD HR B0001570-36-1) Elton John Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (D2) (2004 Rocket SACD HR B0001570-36-2) Elton John Honky Château (2004 Rocket SACD HR B0003609-36) CD, SACD vs LP, Vinyl, Album#CD #vinyl #hifiFor those of you who have not seen my complete music room and system tour and LP, CD SACD tour please click on th. I’m about to open a subjective can of worms here. if one uses the instruments attached to the sides of his head, he will be picking sacd over rbcd. I was still unconvinced. DACs sound different because different DACs apply different filters to the input data and have different methods of producing the analogue signal, even if every DAC used the same chip each DAC's analogue output stage is different. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. Also, do you think SACD has good future in the massive market? I also posted this thread in the "digital" seecion, sorry about that but some people only enter to this section. Not a fair comparison. If it's a hi-res source of unknown origin it will simply say "HR". Sep 23, 2022. The difference between 24/192 and DSD is that the DSD sounds more analog like, but this is not a huge difference in overall sound quality. Not that the SACD doesn't sound really good. Another 3 SACD set, and, if truth be told, my favourite ESOTERIC reissue. The latest in this long history is a double-blind test that, the authors conclude, demonstrates that 44. surround sound or multichannel sound). Oh and if you like SACDs, most of the masters were made on digital audio workstations that are PCM. Also available on: • UHQR Vinyl Record. McLover, Apr 26, 2012 #2. How Much Do We Need To Spend To Hear What CD/SACD or Vinyl Really Has To Offer. Nantes, France. The SACD versions bring the best of the digital versions with the MOFI SACD followed by the 1999 SACD. Low Noise Floor: SACDs tend to have a lower noise floor compared to vinyl records, which means less background noise or surface noise during playback. Thread Tools. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. Blows them all away with more full body richness. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Unfortunately, the vinyl and CDs were impressive but not immersive. Although the MFSL version is very clear and precise, the SACD version is more expansive and full. New items New comments Author list Series Latest content Latest updates Latest reviews. Music, Musicians and Bands; Activity. Add to Cart. But most of us here are comfortable and familiar with it. $12. Consequently, the Super Audio CD (SACD) was developed by Philips and Sony. Maybe but so far my experience with mofi's SACD vs vinyl has not been good for SACS. Vinyl vs SACD. However, I think it's still too early to answer this question even with identically mastered sources recorded and played back on state-of-the-art equipment optimized for. for making the SACD version, and instead they CHOSE James Guthrie, who was an engineer producing, e. " CD or SACD vs Vinyl. The presence of the CD layer shouldn't affect at all (at least in principle) the reading of the SACD layer. During that time, my analog front end has improved and the above-mentioned digital front end has remained the same. Both needed to be set up properly and tracked at their maximum rated vertical tracking force. 1 option. So far my favorites from each format are as follows: SACD: Eric Clapton - Journeyman DVD-A: Fleetwood Mac - Rumors DVD (Dolby Digital/DTS): Eagles. Native DSD64 (SACD) is better still and DSD128 recordings are amazingly good. Kann man diese beiden Formate vergleichen?Analog und Digital? Geht das?Zum abspielen eines SACD Formats benötigt man einen passenden SACD Player. A well-done SACD can sound incredible and can give more detail than an LP. The overall DR between the 2 is very close. . The gap. Although the MFSL version is very clear and precise, the SACD version is more expansive and full. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. Vinyl. #4. Vinyl. Audiogon The world's largest high-end audio community. Virtual. SACD VS Vinyl for Jazz and Classical Well, I've been thinking of getting into vinyl for a while now but still haven't done it. 5 manual RCM then queued up one track at a time. DSD vs SACD vs Vinyl Whenever I look for an older album or artist, seemingly WITHOUT FAIL they are not available as a DSD download. Page 2 of 2 < Prev 1 2. Just trust your ears, as I do mine. If you're a big classical/jazz listener, SACD is completely worth it. I'm generally rather selective about my SACD purchases and only have about 25-30SACD recordings now although I plan to order a lot more as more and more reissues come out. I don't know which is more truthful. A masterpiece SACD set. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Fred Dender and Grampire like this. According to a theorem called. The answer to that question is a qualified yes. Which format do you like the most, or find to be the closest to the original master tapes? Or, if you attend live concerts (or play and instrument), whi. The Dark Side of the Moon produced two singles: "Money" and "Us and Them. CD: SACD’s high resolution and dynamic range typically exceed those of standard CDs, resulting in a potentially more detailed and accurate listening experience. vinyl. Szeppelin75 Forum Resident. Posted August 3, 2011. KevinP Forum introvert. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Re: Super audio cd vs dvd audio. Location: West Hollywood, CA and Inverness, IL. Even better than the regular SACD with even clearer presentation. Menu. It's about the music you like. In. . 2. . Maybe no better overall than any other version. it's stickly limited to 7500 copies. Sorry about my bad English. Limited Edition Numbered SACD CMOB 2260 SA $29. SACD vs. The question of whether SACD sounds better is subjective and nuanced. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. This album can sound really good. Tracks (7) Aja — Steely Dan's landmark sixth studio album reissue. SACD vs. Smoother, more open, and slightly fuller than redbook, without the added distortion of vinyl or the oddness in the upper registers heard on SACD. On September 16th Analogue Productions announced they will reissue the entire ABC/MCA Records Steely Dan catalog on SACD, and 45rpm UHQR LP, beginning November 4th with their debut album Can't Buy A Thrill, now in its 50th anniversary year. Tiny imperfections in the belts or wheels of the turntable will cause more. Most are remasters of jazz, blues, classical or classic rock/pop titles. OTOH, there are many recordings from the 60s, 70s, and 80s that are of poor sound quality. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. SHM-SACD vs Original LP/Original LP-rip, Original CD and other reissues. 5 gigabytes (GB) Advantages of SACD. . The fact that the DSD pulse train VISUALLY happens to look more like the analog signal than the string of binary numbers that result from PCM encoding is meaningless - since both must be converted to analog audio anyway. Dynamics are out of this world. The ABCX-758A/B as mentioned above is my favorite. Yesterday I received a Holiday Specials brochure from Music Direct and on the back cover is the 2LP vinyl set that Ralphie discussed in his post HERE. It's rather disingenuous to claim 150 dB dynamic range for CD audio. The vocals are real, the acoustic guitars are EQ'd perfectly. NorthNY Mark and Espen R like this. Get the DCC Gold CD of the Platinum-SHM mastering. The choice between the two depends on personal preferences and the desired. The SHM CD would have an edge over standard CD but would not surpass Vinyl and SACD, DVD-A if the pressing is mastered properly. I've got a pretty good setup for vinyl and digital audio files, but I have an opportunity to get a "minty" 10-yr old audiophile-grade CD/SACD player for $350. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Boy, what a difference. As to the two selections, one is the Bob James Trio – “Espresso ” and the second is chlara. 4) Making Movies - muted, no drum slam, muted highs. SACD (white) vs Bluray (blue) The pressing quality of 2022 vinyl is not always perfect, but often a wash will solve the problem. IMHO. I bought 2 each ten years ago or so. SACD vs. Thank you. I still prefer vinyl, but I simply do not listen to CD's any more the digital fatigue compared to the SACD's is just too. SACD is not always better than some CD. Noone else has a date. Quote: Originally Posted by regal The sampling rate 44. I do have an unwrapped Cramberries (best of) SHM CD with me. Every time. . This one is the best sounding by far. Even on masterings I'm not all that happy with, the deep soundstage is there. SACD offers pristine, high-resolution digital audio with exceptional detail, while vinyl provides a warm, analog character and a tactile, nostalgic experience. I would think that the Vinyl will sound better than the standard CD. Alan Blumlien of EMI in the 1930’s patented analog stereo, to be first used on. Similar to what I notice. Other than that, the DSD bit stream should be exactly the same for the SACD part. Which format do you like the most, or find to be the closest to the original master tapes? Or, if you attend live concerts (or play and instrument), which format do you prefer and why? wenterprisesnw 02-04-2000 7:53pm. But I don't have an LP with the exact same mastering as an SACD so I can't do any type of apples-to-apples comparison (and even then equipment comes in to play). The SACD format supports multiple audio channels, a very high digital sampling rate, and longer playing time. • The first international release of the recording on Hybrid SACDs, allowing listeners to hear the enhanced resolution of these new transfers and playable on all CD players • The first and only complete Wagner Ring cycle available in Dolby Atmos Channel separation. It sounds great; a very good remastering job. In the vinyl vs. Vinyl. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. It’s appalling the crap they’re releasing to kids these days… Cheap recycled vinyl, pushing the acetate to the limit or until it’ ground in some spots. Third - Single side Japanese SACD . Doug Sax was also involved with the mastering of these CDs. The "Mastertape" version though more detailed and seemingly purer sounds flatter in eq. . Also note that the CD vs Vinyl, or Digital vs Analog is a pointless debate because it is not the format that compromises music, it is the content. SACD's can tend to have better mastering and transfer than standard CD releases of the same album. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. Blue Note sacds), I already have records of. 192 is significantly better and DXD (352) is even better. I don't know which is more truthful. View Profile View Forum Posts Private Message Visit Homepage . Quick links. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. . Mirror Image Forum Resident. Fred Dender and Grampire like this. This is the SACD that was recommended by Steve and it is the best I've heard so far. Moody Blues "Question of bal. Order by Phone Toll Free 1-888-926-2564 Fax 785-825-0156 Phone Outside USA 785-825-8609 Email UsMoody Blues "Question of bal. If you like SACDs, the 2004 reissue of Relaxin’ by the Miles Davis Quintet sounds equally fantastic, albeit a little different with a brighter high end and more noticeable amounts of tape hiss. . vinyl, I'm surprised no one has brought up the concept of DSD's "euphoric distortion" and how that might relate to the perception of increased sound quality. I'm generally rather selective about my SACD purchases and only have about 25-30SACD recordings now although I plan to order a lot more as more and more reissues come out. I found pretty cheap options in my local stores with used items: DVD player - Philips DVD-SACD 763SA (has SACD support) SACD player - SONY SCD-XE670. Headquartered in Salina, Kansas, Acoustic Sounds, Inc. Both sound great but I only want to keep one. It's very difficult to set up a direct A/B comparison between SACD and CD. comparing your AV receiver's DAC to your CD player's DAC is completely valid. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. Analog sources- CD vs. Analog Format. Note the word “indistinguishable. Seems like for PG3 one should definitely get Classic Records Vinyl, for PG1 SACD gets closer to vinyl, but still the vinyl has upper hand. " For classical I prefer SACD due to the format's running time though. Super Audio CD (SACD) is an optical disc format for audio storage introduced in 1999. New media New comments Browse Albums Search media. High Resolution: SACD offers a significantly higher sample rate and bit depth, resulting in more accurate and. onlyconnect, Sep 19, 2020. All we need here is a study showing listeners preferred the 24/192 version of an album over its 16/44 counterpart in a rigorous study. SACD vs. SACD debate, there is no definitive answer to which format offers the ultimate listening experience. The recording/tracking ability of vinyl is easily at least 50 kHz and perhaps as high as 100 kHz. Decca’s landmark recording of Wagner’s 15-hour epic, Der Ring des Nibelungen conducted by Sir Georg Solti is the most celebrated classical recording in history. is the world leader in audiophile music. Weirdly, the reviewer concluded that Vinyl is superior to SACD/DVD-A. The OP asked specifically if an SHM-Platinum CD sounds better than the redbook layer of a Hybrid-SACD. Would someone out there who has the vinyl and has compared it to either the MFSL CD or the newer SACD please. So, Changes CD is DR 12 and Changes SACD is DR 11. Search titles only By:Zucchero "Sugar" Fornaciari - Miserere (Overture)1. At current SACD and vinyl reissue prices I sure do. It's great for archiving, in it's day. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. Hi-res digital audio vs sacd I've got a pretty good setup for vinyl and digital audio files, but I have an opportunity to get a "minty" 10-yr old audiophile-grade CD/SACD player for $350. I chose Mono because these titles interested me the most.